How to Screen Tenants in California – The Ultimate Guide for Landlords

Finding the right tenant in California is one of the most important steps a landlord can take to protect their rental property and maintain a predictable cash flow. A strong tenant screening process does more than check a credit score. It allows landlords to evaluate reliability, confirm income stability, understand rental history, and stay compliant with California’s strict screening and Fair Housing requirements. When done correctly, tenant screening helps landlords avoid problem renters, reduce turnover, and prevent costly disputes.

Before you hand over the keys, it is essential to follow a clear, consistent, and legally compliant screening system. This guide breaks down exactly how California landlords can screen tenants with confidence while staying aligned with state and federal laws.

Key Takeaways

  • California has some of the most detailed tenant screening laws in the country, and landlords must follow them carefully.
  • A legally compliant screening system includes written criteria, consent forms, credit and background checks, rental history verification, and objective review practices.
  • Application fee rules change under AB 2493, which takes effect in 2025, and all landlords must understand how to handle fees and refunds correctly.
  • Consistency, documentation, and fairness are essential for protecting your business and reducing risk.
  • Strong screening protects your rental property, your income, and your long-term peace of mind.
How to Screen Tenants in California - The Ultimate Guide for Landlords

Table of Contents

  • Understanding Tenant Screening
  • What a Tenant Screening Report Includes
  • California’s Legal Framework for Tenant Screening
  • Step-by-Step Tenant Screening Checklist
  • Screening Costs and Application Fees in California
  • Best Practices for Objective and Legal Screening
  • Recommended Tools and Screening Platforms for Landlords
  • Common Screening Mistakes to Avoid
  • Conclusion

Understanding Tenant Screening

Tenant screening is the evaluation process landlords use to determine whether a prospective renter is likely to pay rent consistently, care for the property, and respect the rules of the rental agreement. In California, where eviction timelines and regulations are strict, screening becomes even more critical. A screening process helps landlords reduce risk by verifying identities, confirming income, reviewing financial and rental histories, and assessing fit based on written screening criteria.

Strong screening is a business tool. It allows landlords to make informed decisions rather than emotional ones, and it helps avoid long-term issues such as nonpayment, property damage, or disruptive behavior. California landlords benefit most when the screening process is structured, documented, and fully compliant with local and statewide laws.

What a Tenant Screening Report Includes

A tenant screening report compiles multiple sources of data into a single profile of a prospective renter. Depending on the service you use, the report may include:

Credit History

Credit reports provide insight into financial responsibility. Landlords can review payment history, open accounts, outstanding debts, credit scores, and past bankruptcies.

Eviction Records

An eviction record can indicate past issues with nonpayment, lease violations, or conflicts with housing providers. While not every eviction is a red flag, patterns or unresolved judgments should be evaluated carefully.

Criminal Background Checks

Criminal screenings help landlords understand public safety risks. California landlords must evaluate each case individually and avoid blanket exclusions, but they may still consider recent or serious convictions as part of a risk assessment.

Rental History Verification

Previous landlords can reveal whether a tenant paid rent on time, followed property rules, and left the unit in good condition.

Employment and Income Verification

This helps confirm the applicant can sustainably afford rent. Pay stubs, tax returns, and employment letters are commonly used.

Each component of a screening report gives landlords a different piece of the puzzle, allowing for a more complete and legally sound applicant review.

Federal Laws

Landlords must comply with two major federal regulations during screening.

Fair Housing Act

This law prohibits discrimination based on race, color, religion, national origin, sex, familial status, or disability. Landlords must apply the same criteria to every applicant and avoid questions that relate to protected classes.

Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA)

This statute governs how consumer reports are used. Landlords must:

  • Get written consent before pulling any report.
  • Provide an adverse action notice if rejecting an applicant based on report findings.
  • Give applicants the contact information of the reporting agency.

Compliance at the federal level protects landlords from lawsuits and ensures transparency for applicants.

California Laws and AB 2493 Rules

California expands federal protections and introduces its own requirements that every landlord must follow.

Additional State-Protected Categories

California adds protections for sexual orientation, gender identity, source of income, age, immigration status, and even natural hairstyles.

Application Screening Fees (California Civil Code 1950.6)

Landlords can only charge actual out-of-pocket screening costs up to a legal maximum. This amount adjusts annually based on inflation.

AB 2493 (Effective January 1, 2025)

This law significantly changes how landlords may collect and refund application fees. Under AB 2493, landlords must choose one of two options:

  1. First come, first qualified
    • Landlords provide written screening criteria in advance.
    • Applications are evaluated in the exact order they are received.
    • Only applicants who were actually considered may be charged a fee.
    • Fees must be refunded to all others.
  2. Full refund model
    • Landlords may collect application fees but must refund the entire amount to any applicant not selected.
    • Refunds must be issued within the required timelines.

Credit Report Requirements

If a landlord pulls a credit report, they must provide the applicant with a copy within seven days, whether requested or not.

California’s legal structure is designed to ensure transparency and fairness, and landlords must stay informed to remain compliant.

Step-by-Step Tenant Screening Checklist

Pre-Screening Questions

Pre-screening helps landlords save time before sending an application. The goal is to identify whether the applicant meets general standards such as income, pets, or move-in timing. Common legal questions include:

  • Employment status
  • Estimated income
  • Reason for moving
  • Expected number of occupants
  • Desired move-in date

Pre-screening questions allow quick alignment without crossing into illegal or discriminatory topics.

Documentation and Screening Criteria

A written set of rental criteria protects both landlords and applicants. Criteria may include:

  • Minimum credit score
  • Income requirements such as two and a half or three times the rent
  • No active bankruptcies
  • No unpaid landlord judgments

Written criteria remove subjectivity and help landlords defend decisions if challenged. Landlords should provide these criteria upfront, especially under AB 2493.

Running Credit, Criminal, and Eviction Checks

Landlords must obtain written consent before ordering any background check. Once consent is received, landlords typically review:

  • Creditworthiness through a recognized bureau
  • Eviction court records
  • Criminal convictions that may pose risk
  • Debt-to-income indicators

This information gives landlords a clear view of a tenant’s financial and behavioral history. Reports should be reviewed carefully and consistently across every applicant.

Reviewing Applications Objectively

California law requires fairness and consistency. To accomplish this, landlords should:

  • Compare each application to the written rental criteria
  • Avoid emotional decision making
  • Document the reason for approval or denial
  • Apply the same evaluation steps to every applicant

Using screening software can reduce human bias and keep a clean record of the decision-making process.

Screening Costs and Application Fees in California

Tenant screening typically includes separate costs for credit checks, criminal background checks, and eviction searches. California caps application fees and only allows landlords to charge what they actually paid, up to a statewide limit that adjusts annually.

Under AB 2493, landlords must either evaluate applicants in the order they were received or refund full application fees to unselected applicants. These rules apply to every rental type, and failure to follow them can result in penalties or disputes.

Landlords can protect themselves by maintaining clear systems that do not change from one applicant to the next. Recommended practices include:

  • Keeping written rental criteria
  • Maintaining consistent communication
  • Using professional screening services
  • Documenting decisions and communications
  • Remaining informed about changes to California housing laws

The more consistent the process, the lower the risk of discrimination claims or applicant disputes.

Several platforms offer screening packages that help California landlords stay compliant and organized. Landlords often choose services that include instant credit reports, eviction searches, income verification tools, and automated adverse action notices. Most services also allow tenants to pay the screening cost directly, which helps landlords maintain a compliant workflow.

Common Screening Mistakes to Avoid

Landlords can unintentionally create legal risk when they:

  • Ask prohibited questions
  • Apply screening criteria inconsistently
  • Charge illegal or inflated application fees
  • Reject applicants without giving an adverse action notice
  • Fail to provide copies of credit reports when required
  • Rely solely on gut instinct rather than written criteria

Avoiding these mistakes strengthens your overall screening system and protects your investment.

Conclusion

Tenant screening in California requires both due diligence and legal awareness. By following written criteria, using reliable reports, complying with state and federal laws, and maintaining a consistent evaluation process, landlords can confidently choose renters who are responsible, stable, and a good fit for their property. The time invested in proper screening pays off in long-term tenancy, reduced turnover, and fewer rental headaches.

You might be interested in…