Leasing to Applicants with Cosigners: A Landlord’s Guide in California - Fast Eviction Service

Leasing to Applicants with Cosigners: A Landlord’s Guide in California

As a California landlord, you’ll occasionally meet prospective tenants who don’t fully meet your screening standards. They might have a limited credit history, insufficient income, or a past rental issue. In these cases, a cosigner for an apartment lease can help bridge the gap, offering financial security while giving a tenant the opportunity to rent responsibly.

However, cosigners introduce unique legal and financial considerations. This guide explains how to safely lease to applicants with cosigners, the differences between cosigners and guarantors, and what California landlords should know to protect their rental business.

Key Takeaways

  • A cosigner shares full legal and financial responsibility for the lease with the tenant.
  • A guarantor backs the lease financially but does not live in the unit or share tenancy rights.
  • Landlords should screen cosigners as thoroughly as tenants to minimize risk.
  • Clear lease addendums and joint liability clauses protect landlords if payments are missed.
  • Cosigners can expand your applicant pool, but they must be handled with due diligence under California law.
Leasing to Applicants with Cosigners: A Landlord’s Guide in California

Table of Contents

What Is a Cosigner and How They Differ from Guarantors

A cosigner is an individual who signs the lease alongside the tenant, assuming equal legal and financial responsibility. If rent isn’t paid or damages occur, the cosigner is fully liable under the lease terms.

In contrast, a guarantor signs a separate agreement promising to cover rent or damages only if the tenant defaults. Guarantors cannot live in the property and typically have no occupancy rights.

California landlords often use both terms interchangeably, but legally they serve different roles. A cosigner is a co-tenant with legal standing, while a guarantor acts as financial security. Understanding this distinction is essential when drafting lease agreements or pursuing unpaid rent.

Why Landlords Accept Applicants with Cosigners

Landlords may consider an applicant with a cosigner when the tenant:

  • Has a low or limited credit score
  • Lacks rental history or proof of income
  • Is a student or first-time renter
  • Has prior evictions or late payments
  • Works in freelance or seasonal employment

From a landlord’s perspective, allowing a cosigner can make the difference between a vacant unit and a reliable tenancy. It widens your pool of potential tenants while providing additional financial security through a secondary liable party.

California law recognizes joint and several liability, meaning both the tenant and cosigner are equally responsible for fulfilling lease obligations. If rent remains unpaid or the property is damaged, the landlord can pursue either party for full repayment.

Landlords should:

  • Ensure the cosigner agreement clearly outlines financial responsibility.
  • Verify that the cosigner understands their obligations before signing.
  • Maintain compliance with California Fair Housing laws, avoiding discrimination based on income source or family status.
  • Understand that a cosigner does not protect against eviction delays, if payment stops, standard notice procedures (like a 3-Day Notice to Pay or Quit) still apply.

Screening and Approving a Cosigner

A cosigner should be screened with the same rigor as a tenant. California landlords should require:

  • Credit score of at least 700
  • Stable employment or verifiable income (ideally 4–5 times monthly rent)
  • Clean rental and criminal history
  • Valid government ID and proof of residency

Run background and credit checks on both tenant and cosigner. Many professional landlords use screening tools such as TransUnion SmartMove or RentPrep to evaluate applicants efficiently.

If the cosigner doesn’t meet your minimum standards, you can still deny the application, provided it complies with fair housing laws and written rental criteria.

Drafting a Cosigner or Guarantor Agreement

Always document the cosigner relationship through a written Lease Cosigner or Guarantor Addendum. This form should include:

  • Full legal names of all parties
  • Lease start and end dates
  • A clear statement of joint and several liability
  • A clause outlining duration of responsibility, including renewals
  • Contact details for the cosigner
  • Signature lines for tenant(s), cosigner, and landlord

Sample clause:

“The Cosigner agrees to be jointly and severally liable for all tenant obligations under this lease, including but not limited to rent, damages, late fees, and attorney costs, for the duration of this agreement and any subsequent renewals.”

Pros and Cons for Landlords

ProsCons
Expands applicant pool without lowering qualification standards
Provides added assurance for rent payments
Reduces vacancy periods and increases leasing flexibility
Enables approval for tenants with limited credit or rental history		Increases administrative tasks (screening, addendums, tracking)
Risk of strained tenant–cosigner relationships affecting payments
Collection may still require legal action if both default
Some landlords prefer to avoid cosigner arrangements altogether

By weighing these factors, California landlords can decide whether accepting a cosigner aligns with their property’s risk tolerance and policies.

Best Practices for California Landlords

  1. Set clear criteria: Define when a cosigner is required and communicate it in your rental policy.
  2. Use written agreements: Avoid verbal promises, everything should be documented.
  3. Screen consistently: Apply the same screening standards to all applicants to avoid Fair Housing violations.
  4. Educate the cosigner: Make sure they understand the financial risks involved.
  5. Maintain professional boundaries: The cosigner is not a “backup tenant” but a financial guarantor.
  6. Monitor payments: Notify both tenant and cosigner of any late rent immediately.
  7. Use enforceable documents: Consider consulting a local housing specialist to ensure your forms comply with California regulations.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

  • Failing to screen the cosigner thoroughly
  • Forgetting to attach the cosigner agreement to the lease
  • Allowing a cosigner to move in without revising the contract
  • Assuming a cosigner can be held responsible indefinitely after lease termination
  • Ignoring local rent control ordinances or security deposit limits under California Civil Code §1950.5

Avoiding these mistakes helps landlords reduce disputes, maintain compliance, and protect rental income.

Key Takeaways for Property Managers

  • Always use a written, signed guarantee agreement.
  • Verify financial capacity of every cosigner, don’t assume family means reliability.
  • Treat cosigners as part of the leasing process, not a backup plan.
  • Remember: you can pursue the cosigner for damages or unpaid rent under joint liability.

Having issues with cosigners? We can help!

Conclusion

Leasing to applicants with cosigners can be a strategic move for California landlords, expanding your tenant pool while maintaining financial security. The key lies in proper screening, solid documentation, and clear communication with both the tenant and the cosigner.

Handled correctly, a cosigner arrangement protects your property investment, minimizes vacancies, and helps responsible tenants secure housing they otherwise couldn’t.

You might be interested in…