Residential & Commercial Evictions | You are represented at all times by one of our California Eviction Attorneys | 1-800-686-8686 | intake@fastevict.com | Se habla español
Tenant Background Checks Explained: What Landlords Should Review Before Approving an Applicant
Finding a reliable tenant is one of the most important decisions a California landlord can make. A good tenant can mean years of consistent rent payments and fewer property management headaches. A poor screening decision, on the other hand, can lead to unpaid rent, property damage, and potentially an expensive eviction.
That’s why tenant background checks are such an important part of the rental process.
But here’s something landlords sometimes overlook: It’s not just what you discover during a background check that matters. How you collect application fees, review applicants, and make your final decision matters just as much.
California has specific rules governing rental applications, consumer reports, screening fees, and tenant selection. Under Assembly Bill 2493, which took effect January 1, 2025, landlords must also follow one of two permitted procedures when collecting application screening fees.
Whether you own one rental home or manage multiple properties throughout Southern California, understanding these requirements can help you make more informed decisions while reducing unnecessary legal exposure.
Key Takeaways
- Tenant background checks help California landlords evaluate credit history, income, rental history, identity, and other legally relevant information.
- California Civil Code Section 1950.6 regulates rental application screening fees, receipts, refunds, and application procedures.
- AB 2493 gives landlords two screening fee options: Follow a first-qualified applicant process or refund screening fees to applicants who are not selected.
- Written screening criteria are required when using the first-qualified applicant procedure and are a valuable best practice for all landlords.
- Application fees are limited to permitted screening costs and cannot exceed the applicable CPI-adjusted maximum.
- Refund deadlines matter. Depending on the procedure used, landlords may have seven-day or 30-day refund obligations.
- Fair housing compliance is essential. Landlords must consider federal, California, and applicable local restrictions before making rental decisions.

Table of Contents
- What Is a Tenant Background Check?
- What Is Included in a Tenant Screening Report?
- Why Tenant Background Checks Matter
- Legal Rules California Landlords Should Know
- California Tenant Screening Fees and AB 2493
- First Qualified Applicant vs. Refundable Screening Fees
- When California Landlords Must Refund Application Fees
- Common Problems With Tenant Screening Reports
- How to Set Fair and Consistent Screening Criteria
- How to Choose a Tenant Screening Service
- Best Practices for California Tenant Background Checks
- Frequently Asked Questions
What Is a Tenant Background Check?
A tenant background check is the process landlords use to evaluate prospective renters before entering into a rental agreement.
The purpose is straightforward: determine whether an applicant meets reasonable, legally permissible qualifications for renting the property.
A typical California rental application screening process involves reviewing financial information, verifying identity, confirming rental history, and obtaining authorized consumer reports.
For example, imagine you’re renting a single-family home in Riverside County. You receive an application from someone who reports steady employment, sufficient income, and several years of positive rental history.
Rather than relying solely on the information provided, a background check allows you to verify relevant details through appropriate sources.
The process may reveal inconsistencies that deserve further review, or it may confirm that the applicant meets your established qualifications.
The important distinction is that tenant screening should be based on legitimate rental qualifications, not personal assumptions or preferences.
What Is Included in a Tenant Screening Report?
A comprehensive tenant screening report may include several types of information. Each provides a different perspective on an applicant’s qualifications.
Credit Report and Credit Score
Credit reports help landlords understand how an applicant has managed financial obligations.
Depending on the report, you may see payment history, outstanding debts, collection accounts, and other credit-related information.
However, a credit score doesn’t tell the entire story.
An applicant might have a lower score because of medical debt or a limited credit history while still having a consistent record of paying rent.
Rather than focusing exclusively on one number, landlords should evaluate credit information according to their established, legally permissible screening standards.
California landlords should also remember that certain subsidized housing applicants have additional protections involving alternative methods of demonstrating financial eligibility.
Criminal Background Checks
Criminal background screening requires particular care in California.
A landlord cannot assume that every criminal record automatically disqualifies an applicant. California fair housing regulations restrict the types of records housing providers may consider and generally require an individualized assessment of directly related convictions.
For example, an old conviction unrelated to the applicant’s ability to fulfill rental obligations should not automatically be treated the same as a recent conviction with a direct connection to a substantial property or resident safety concern.
Arrests without convictions, sealed records, and certain other criminal history information are also subject to restrictions.
Landlords should review applicable California and local fair housing rules before ordering or relying on criminal background information.
Eviction History
Eviction-related information may help landlords evaluate an applicant’s prior rental history, but these records require careful interpretation.
An eviction filing is not necessarily proof that a tenant was evicted. Some cases are dismissed, resolved, or decided in the tenant’s favor.
California also restricts access to and use of certain eviction records, including sealed unlawful detainer cases and protected COVID-19 rental debt information.
Landlords should avoid treating every eviction-related entry as an automatic disqualification.
When legally permissible information raises concerns, reviewing the underlying circumstances can help prevent inaccurate conclusions.
Identity Verification
Identity verification helps ensure the person submitting an application matches the information being reviewed.
This is particularly important when landlords rely on third-party screening companies or receive applications electronically.
Verification may involve government-issued identification and comparison of identifying information.
California landlords should not assume that every applicant must possess a Social Security number or California driver’s license. Alternative identification may be appropriate, and inquiries into immigration status are restricted.
Employment and Income Verification
Verifying income helps landlords determine whether an applicant can reasonably afford the monthly rent.
Common documents include pay statements, employment verification, bank records, and other reliable evidence of income.
However, California’s source-of-income protections mean landlords cannot automatically reject applicants simply because they receive housing assistance or rely on lawful nonemployment income.
For example, an applicant using a Section 8 housing voucher must be evaluated under applicable source-of-income protections. Where required, income-based screening standards must account for the portion of rent the applicant is personally responsible for paying.
The goal is to verify financial qualifications without unlawfully excluding applicants based on how they receive their income.
Why Tenant Background Checks Matter
Tenant screening is one of the few opportunities landlords have to evaluate potential rental risks before a tenancy begins.
Once a tenant takes possession, resolving serious payment problems or lease violations can become significantly more complicated.
A thorough screening process helps landlords evaluate relevant information before making that commitment.
It can also improve operational efficiency.
Consider a property manager handling several vacancies across Los Angeles, Orange, and San Bernardino Counties. Without a consistent procedure, applications may be reviewed differently depending on who receives them or how busy the office happens to be.
A documented screening process creates a more predictable system.
It helps staff understand which information to request, how to evaluate applications, when fees may be collected, and what records should be maintained.
Just as importantly, it creates documentation that may help explain how a rental decision was reached if questions arise later.
Legal Rules California Landlords Should Know
California landlords must consider several overlapping legal requirements when conducting tenant background checks.
Authorization and Consumer Reporting Requirements
Tenant screening reports are generally consumer reports regulated by the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act and applicable California consumer reporting laws.
Landlords must have a permissible purpose to obtain these reports.
A clear, documented authorization procedure is a prudent way to establish the applicant’s permission and comply with applicable reporting-service requirements. The precise consent requirements depend on the type of report and applicable law, so landlords should not assume that every type of tenant report is governed by an identical federal written-consent rule.
Adverse Action Notices
Suppose a landlord reviews a screening report and decides to reject an application because of information contained in that report.
Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act, an adverse action notice is generally required when a consumer report contributes to an unfavorable rental decision.
This requirement can also apply when a landlord imposes less favorable rental terms based on information from the report.
The notice generally identifies the reporting company, explains that the reporting company did not make the rental decision, and informs the applicant of applicable rights to obtain and dispute the report.
Landlords should maintain a consistent procedure for issuing these notices.
Fair Housing Considerations
Federal and California fair housing laws prohibit discrimination based on protected characteristics.
California protections include race, religion, disability, familial status, source of income, and several additional characteristics.
Screening policies must also account for reasonable accommodations and other legally required exceptions.
A policy that appears neutral may still create legal concerns if it disproportionately excludes protected applicants without adequate justification.
Local ordinances may impose additional requirements, so landlords should verify the rules applicable to the property’s city and any relevant housing program.
California Tenant Screening Fees and AB 2493
One of the most important areas of California tenant screening compliance involves application fees.
Landlords commonly charge these fees to cover credit reports, background screening services, reference checks, and reasonable time spent gathering applicant information.
However, California does not allow landlords to treat application fees as unrestricted processing revenue.
Under California Civil Code Section 1950.6, application screening fees must comply with restrictions governing their amount, collection, documentation, and refund.
AB 2493, effective January 1, 2025, introduced additional requirements concerning how landlords collect these fees and process applications.
How Much Can California Landlords Charge for a Screening Fee in 2026?
California law establishes a screening fee maximum based on a $30 statutory amount, adjusted annually for increases in the Consumer Price Index.
For 2026, the California Apartment Association identifies a CPI-adjusted maximum of $65.86 per applicant.
However, this figure is a ceiling, not an automatic amount that every landlord can charge.
The fee must also be limited to the actual permitted costs of gathering applicant information, including eligible screening service expenses and the reasonable value of time spent obtaining that information.
For example, if a landlord’s allowable screening costs total $42, the landlord cannot simply charge $65.86 because that is the published maximum.
Landlords should verify the applicable CPI calculation and any local or program-specific restrictions before establishing or updating screening fees.
Written Screening Criteria and Application Procedures
Under AB 2493, landlords who choose the first-qualified applicant screening procedure must provide their established screening criteria in writing together with the application form.
These criteria should explain the qualifications used to evaluate applications.
They might address income verification, credit requirements, rental history, documentation requirements, and other legally permissible factors.
Having written standards makes the process easier for applicants to understand and helps landlords evaluate applications more consistently.
It also reduces the likelihood of changing requirements after receiving an application.
Even when landlords choose the alternative refundable-fee procedure, maintaining written criteria remains an important business practice.
Itemized Screening Fee Receipts
California landlords must provide applicants who pay screening fees with itemized receipts.
The receipt should identify the applicable out-of-pocket screening expenses and time spent obtaining and processing applicant information.
For example, if a landlord charges for a credit report and reference verification, the receipt should identify the corresponding expenses and permitted time charges.
The receipt may be delivered personally or by mail. Email delivery is also permitted when the landlord and applicant agree.
Landlords should retain copies of receipts and supporting records.
No Screening Fees When No Rental Unit Is Available
California Civil Code Section 1950.6 prohibits landlords from charging an application screening fee when they know, or reasonably should know, that no rental unit is available or will become available within a reasonable period.
Consider a landlord advertising a property that has already been rented.
Continuing to collect application fees from interested renters simply to build a waiting list would create compliance concerns.
Before collecting fees, landlords should confirm that an actual rental opportunity exists.
Providing Copies of Credit Reports
When an applicant has paid an application screening fee and the landlord obtains a consumer credit report, California law requires the landlord to provide the applicant with a copy within seven days after receiving it.
The report may be provided through personal delivery, mail, or email.
This requirement is separate from the landlord’s obligation to issue an adverse action notice when applicable.
Landlords should establish an administrative process to ensure credit reports are delivered within the required timeframe.
First Qualified Applicant vs. Refundable Screening Fees
A particularly important provision of AB 2493 is that landlords have two alternative screening fee procedures.
Understanding the difference can help landlords select a process that works for their rental operations while meeting California law.
Option 1: First Qualified Applicant Screening Process
Under this approach, landlords review completed applications in the order they are received.
The established screening criteria must be provided in writing with the application.
The first applicant who satisfies those criteria is approved for tenancy.
Importantly, a landlord cannot charge an application screening fee unless or until that applicant’s application is actually considered.
Here’s an example.
A landlord receives three completed applications for a rental home in Orange County.
The first applicant meets all established screening criteria. Under the first-qualified approach, that applicant must be approved rather than being passed over simply because another applicant has a higher credit score or earns more money.
If the second and third applications are never considered, those applicants should not be charged screening fees.
If a fee is inadvertently collected from an applicant whose application is not considered because multiple applications were submitted concurrently, the landlord must refund it within seven days.
The landlord may offer to apply that fee toward another available rental offered by the landlord, but the applicant must agree.
If an application is actually considered and denied because the applicant fails to meet the established criteria, the landlord generally does not have to refund the properly collected screening fee under this option, subject to other applicable refund requirements.
Option 2: Refund Screening Fees to Applicants Who Are Not Selected
California also permits a different approach.
Under this option, the landlord may collect screening fees using a process that provides a full refund to every applicant who is not selected for tenancy, regardless of the reason.
This includes applicants whose applications were reviewed but who were ultimately denied.
For example, suppose a landlord receives four applications for a rental property in San Diego.
After evaluating the applications using lawful screening standards, the landlord selects one applicant.
Under the refundable-fee option, the landlord must return the entire screening fee to each of the three applicants who were not selected.
The refund must be made within seven days of selecting an applicant or within 30 days of the application being submitted, whichever occurs first.
This option may provide additional flexibility in the application evaluation process, but it does not eliminate fair housing obligations or other screening requirements.
Comparing California’s Two Screening Fee Options
| Requirement | First Qualified Approach | Refundable Fee Approach |
| Written screening criteria | Must be provided with application | Recommended, and other disclosure rules may apply |
| Application order | Completed applications reviewed in order received | No identical first-qualified sequencing requirement under this option |
| Tenant selection | First applicant meeting established criteria is approved | Selection must follow lawful, nondiscriminatory standards |
| Fee collection | Only when application is actually considered | Permitted subject to statutory conditions |
| Applicant denied after review | Fee generally may be retained if denied for failing criteria | Entire fee must be refunded |
| Applicant not considered | No fee should be charged; inadvertent fees refunded | Unselected applicants receive full refunds |
| Refund timing | Seven days for inadvertently collected fees on unconsidered applications | Seven days after selection or 30 days after submission, whichever is earlier |
The important takeaway: California does not require every landlord to use the first-qualified approach. However, landlords collecting application screening fees must comply with one of the two statutory procedures.
When California Landlords Must Refund Application Fees
Refund requirements are another area where administrative mistakes can create unnecessary problems.
A landlord might properly obtain a credit report and still owe a refund because the selected screening fee procedure requires one.
The following situations deserve particular attention.
When an Application Was Never Considered
Under the first-qualified procedure, applicants generally should not be charged until their applications are actually considered.
If multiple applications arrive at nearly the same time and a landlord inadvertently collects a fee from someone whose application is never reviewed, the fee must be refunded within seven days.
Simply receiving an application does not necessarily mean the landlord has considered it.
When an Applicant Is Not Selected Under the Refundable Fee Option
Under the alternative refundable-fee procedure, the landlord must refund the entire screening fee to any applicant not selected for tenancy.
The deadline is the earlier of:
- Seven days after another applicant is selected.
- Thirty days after the application was submitted.
For example, if a landlord receives an application on June 1 and selects another tenant on June 10, the refund must be issued within seven days after the selection.
If no selection has occurred by the applicable 30-day deadline, the landlord cannot simply hold the fee indefinitely.
When Part of the Screening Fee Was Not Used
California also requires landlords to return screening fee amounts that were not used for authorized purposes.
For example, if a landlord collects an amount intended to cover both a credit report and reference verification but does not perform all of the anticipated screening activities, the landlord must determine whether any portion must be returned.
Maintaining an itemized record of actual screening expenses makes this process easier.
How Landlords Can Avoid Refund Mistakes
Consider keeping a simple application tracking system.
Record when each completed application was received, which screening procedure applies, when the application was reviewed, whether a fee was collected, the final decision, and any applicable refund deadline.
For landlords handling several vacancies simultaneously, this can prevent confusion and missed refunds.
Common Problems With Tenant Screening Reports
Even reputable screening services can produce incomplete or inaccurate information.
A report may contain outdated information, records belonging to another person, or entries that require additional verification.
For landlords, the challenge is distinguishing legitimate rental concerns from information that should not be relied upon.
Incorrect or Outdated Information
Suppose a screening report shows an unpaid account that the applicant claims was resolved several years earlier.
Automatically rejecting the application without considering the accuracy of the information may create avoidable problems.
Landlords should understand the reporting service’s dispute procedures and comply with applicable consumer reporting requirements.
Relying Too Heavily on Credit Scores
Credit scores can be useful, but they should not replace a thoughtful evaluation of legally relevant financial information.
An applicant with limited credit history may have a strong record of rental payments.
Another applicant might have a higher score but insufficient verified income.
Established screening criteria help landlords evaluate these situations more consistently.
Misinterpreting Criminal or Eviction Records
Criminal history and eviction records can be particularly sensitive.
California law restricts the use of certain records, and local ordinances may impose additional protections.
Landlords should ensure their screening service provides legally reportable information and that their evaluation procedures comply with applicable restrictions.
Inconsistent Application Processing
Another common problem has little to do with the screening report itself.
A landlord may review one applicant immediately, delay another application, collect fees from everyone, and fail to document when decisions were made.
These administrative inconsistencies can become especially problematic under AB 2493.
A well-organized application workflow is just as important as selecting a reliable screening company.
How to Set Fair and Consistent Screening Criteria
Written screening criteria are one of the best ways to make the rental application process more predictable.
Before advertising a vacancy, landlords should identify the qualifications they intend to use.
For example, criteria might address acceptable documentation, lawful income verification standards, rental references, and how credit information will be evaluated.
The requirements should be reasonably related to legitimate rental considerations and comply with fair housing laws.
Establish Criteria Before Accepting Applications
Avoid creating or changing requirements after reviewing individual applicants.
If a landlord decides that one applicant must provide additional financial documentation but does not impose comparable requirements on similarly situated applicants, questions about inconsistent treatment may arise.
Clear standards help prevent these situations.
Account for Source-of-Income Protections
California prohibits discrimination based on lawful sources of income, including housing assistance vouchers.
Landlords should understand how these protections affect income calculations and rental qualification procedures.
A screening policy that works for an applicant paying the entire rent personally may require a different legally compliant calculation for someone receiving rental assistance.
Review Reasonable Accommodation Requests
Landlords must also consider applicable reasonable accommodation obligations for applicants with disabilities.
For example, a rigid documentation or procedural requirement may need to be modified when a legally required reasonable accommodation applies.
Consistency does not mean refusing every exception. It means applying lawful standards fairly while recognizing circumstances where the law requires different treatment.
Keep Records of Screening Decisions
Documenting the process helps establish what occurred.
Useful records may include application submission dates, written criteria, screening authorizations, report delivery confirmations, fee receipts, refund records, and decision notices.
Personal information should be stored securely and retained only as appropriate under applicable legal requirements and recordkeeping policies.
How to Choose a Tenant Screening Service
Not all tenant screening services offer the same features or compliance support.
Some provide basic credit information, while others offer identity verification, rental history reporting, and additional background information.
For California landlords, the best service is not necessarily the one providing the most data.
It is the one that supplies accurate, legally usable information and supports a compliant application process.
Look for Accurate and Legally Appropriate Reports
Choose a provider that explains its data sources, reporting limitations, and dispute procedures.
The service should understand restrictions affecting criminal history, eviction records, and consumer reporting.
Consider California-Specific Administrative Features
A useful screening platform may help landlords:
- Record completed application submission times.
- Provide written screening criteria.
- Track when applications are actually reviewed.
- Generate itemized screening fee receipts.
- Manage required credit report delivery.
- Identify screening fee refund obligations.
- Maintain appropriate application records.
These features can be particularly valuable for property managers handling multiple vacancies.
Understand Who Collects the Screening Fee
Some services collect fees directly from applicants, while others bill landlords.
However, using a third-party platform does not automatically eliminate a landlord’s legal obligations.
Landlords should understand how the platform handles fees, receipts, refunds, and report delivery before relying on it.
Consider Reusable Tenant Screening Reports
California Civil Code Section 1950.1 addresses reusable tenant screening reports.
Landlords generally are not required to accept these reports, but if they choose to accept a qualifying reusable report, they cannot charge the applicant a screening fee or a fee to access that report.
Understanding this option may help landlords reduce duplicate screening expenses while maintaining a consistent process.
Best Practices for California Tenant Background Checks
A successful tenant screening process starts before the first application arrives.
Landlords should determine how applications will be collected, what information will be reviewed, and which screening fee procedure will apply.
For example, a landlord preparing to rent a condominium in Los Angeles County might begin by establishing written screening criteria and confirming that the property is actually available.
Next, the landlord should verify that the application platform can document completed application submission times and properly handle screening fees.
Once applications arrive, the landlord can follow the selected screening procedure, review legally permissible information, and document decisions.
If an applicant is denied based on a consumer report, the landlord should issue any required adverse action notice.
If a refund is required, the landlord should process it within the applicable deadline.
Finally, screening records should be retained securely according to the landlord’s recordkeeping obligations.
The goal is to create a repeatable system that protects the landlord’s interests while complying with California law.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does a tenant background check include in California?
A tenant background check may include credit information, rental history, identity verification, employment and income documentation, and legally permissible criminal or eviction records. The information reviewed must comply with applicable consumer reporting and fair housing restrictions.
How much can a landlord charge for a tenant screening fee in California in 2026?
The California Apartment Association identifies a 2026 CPI-adjusted maximum of $65.86 per applicant. However, landlords cannot automatically charge the maximum. The fee must be limited to actual permitted screening costs, and applicable local or program-specific restrictions must also be considered.
Does California require landlords to accept the first qualified applicant?
Not in every situation. Under AB 2493, landlords collecting screening fees may use the first-qualified applicant process or the alternative procedure requiring full refunds to applicants who are not selected. Both options remain subject to applicable fair housing laws.
Can a California landlord keep an application fee if the applicant is denied?
It depends on the screening procedure.
Under the first-qualified approach, a landlord generally may retain a properly collected screening fee when an application was actually considered and denied because the applicant failed to meet established screening criteria.
Under the refundable-fee approach, the landlord must refund the entire screening fee to an applicant who is not selected, regardless of the reason.
Can landlords collect application fees when there is no vacancy?
No. California Civil Code Section 1950.6 prohibits collecting an application screening fee when the landlord knows or should know that no rental unit is available or will become available within a reasonable period.
How quickly must California landlords refund screening fees?
Under the refundable-fee option, landlords must refund unsuccessful applicants within seven days after selecting another applicant or 30 days after the application was submitted, whichever comes first.
Under the first-qualified option, an inadvertently collected fee for an application that was not considered must be refunded within seven days.
Other unused-fee refund requirements may also apply.
Do California landlords have to provide screening fee receipts?
Yes. Landlords collecting application screening fees must provide itemized receipts identifying applicable expenses and time spent obtaining and processing applicant information.
Must landlords provide applicants with copies of their credit reports?
Yes, when an applicant has paid a screening fee and the landlord obtains a consumer credit report, California Civil Code Section 1950.6 requires the landlord to provide a copy within seven days after receiving it.
Can landlords deny applicants based on criminal history?
California restricts how criminal history may be considered in rental decisions. Blanket exclusions and reliance on certain protected records can violate fair housing requirements. Landlords should use legally permissible, individualized evaluations and review any applicable local restrictions.
Are landlords required to accept reusable tenant screening reports?
Generally, no. However, landlords who choose to accept qualifying reusable tenant screening reports cannot charge an application screening fee or a fee to access the report.
Conclusion
Tenant background checks are an important part of protecting rental property investments, but a successful screening process involves much more than ordering a credit report.
California landlords must understand how to evaluate applicants, follow fair housing requirements, collect screening fees properly, and document rental decisions.
AB 2493 has made the application process particularly important by establishing specific procedures for screening fee collection, applicant selection, and refunds.
For landlords throughout Southern California, the best approach is to establish clear screening standards, select an appropriate application procedure, and maintain accurate records from the beginning.
Taking these steps can help reduce avoidable disputes and create a more organized rental operation.
Need assistance with a landlord-tenant issue in Southern California?
Fast Eviction Service helps rental property owners navigate California landlord-tenant matters, including eviction proceedings and related legal concerns.
Contact Fast Eviction Service to learn more about our services.
